I love it when I’ve donated some money to a worthwhile cause like the Red Cross or Amnesty. There’s a site called Lend with Care, that uses your donation to give microfinance loans to help people work themselves out of poverty. It’s a great feeling to know you’re helping real people better themselves. It’s just lovely to be kind. Being kind is a human superpower. It makes us feel good and the world seems like a much better place. However, kindness does more than just make us feel good; it actually bolsters our psychological and physical health. Kindness is linked to improved happiness and a reduction in stress, anxiety, and feelings of isolation. There’s hard science to say it boosts mood, compassion, empathy, and self-esteem. 

But why are we kind? Why is kindness such a beneficial state of being? It is something of a mystery. After all, it has little evolutionary value. According to science, life has to be strong to survive. Genes are selfish. Ruthless even. Kindness is counterintuitive. It often takes away resources from those that have them to give them to competitors. And yet, kindness is a universal force. It is everywhere in the natural world: trees support sickly or diseased neighbours by giving them water and nutrients through their roots, birds warn others of nearby predators, and animals foster babies when they become orphaned. Nature, in contrast to the notions of survival of the fittest we have, is jam-packed full of examples of coexistence, mutual support, and kindness. 

And kindness goes back to every major cultures and great thinkers throughout history. In Taoism, kindness is a core virtue that involves living in harmony with the Tao, being compassionate to oneself and others, and embracing simplicity, patience, and balance. In ancient Greece, kindness was embodied by Philophrosyne, representing hospitality and positive social interactions, and was a sacred duty known as xenia. The Bible emphasises kindness throughout its verses too, encouraging followers to show love, compassion, and gentleness, as seen in Jesus’ teachings. The Quran also emphasises kindness throughout, encouraging believers to embody kindness in their daily lives. In this way, kindness is the epitome of virtue and compassionate living.

Scientists have had many theories as to why kindness should be so beneficial to life. It used to be believed that organisms behaved cooperatively as a way of promoting the species, known as “group selection theory”, but this is now regarded with scepticism. It may partly be that helping those similar to us is a way of passing on our genes, but this does not explain benevolence towards those who do not share them. Another idea is shared altruism – “I’ll scratch your back, if you scratch mine”, but again, this does not explain kindness to strangers you’ll never meet again or when no one will see you do it. So while kindness does not explicitly contradict evolution, it cannot be fully explained by it either. It seems as though kindness has other properties that transcend mere genetic inheritance. 

Again, I’m left to wonder, why is life like this? It is easy to just bail out here and say ‘we don’t know. It’s just one of life’s oddities. A mysterious by-product of being alive.’ That, in my opinion, is a cop-out. I suppose if you’re one of those people that believe the whole universe is a freak accident with no cause or purpose, then it’s not much of a shocker to believe kindness is similarly random. For me though, this is evidence of purpose. It supports my belief that this is all part of a grand design – that being kind is hard-wired into the fabric of the universe for a reason. This is my God, talking to me, showing me His universe and laying out His purpose for me to see. It is His way of showing me the route back to Him and kindness is His guiding light. To be kind, is to get closer to the Divine essence of our nature, and so for me, the mystery of why kindness is so ubiquitous is solved.

Sources

Why is it nice to be nice?

The healing power of kindness

The false allure of group selection

Paul Carney Avatar

Published by

12 responses to “The kindness conundrum ”

  1. David Pearce Music Reviewer Avatar

    I have taught in primary classes and I have definitely found the opposite, but that is very likely to be because I was unconsciously looking for it. However, I can say that where I have seen bullying, it’s spread through the class, perhaps through fear of being the next target. You clearly have a much more positive view of human nature than I do and I admire you for that. I know that my early experiences of being bullied have made me inherently negative in terms of how I view other people, but I can only see bullies in positions of power in education, business and politics. Again that could well be that I am looking for it. I do enjoy my preconceptions being challenged, whether or not it eventually changes my viewpoint. What I will do is remain open to those challengers like your good self. 👍👍

    1. Paul Carney Avatar

      Yeah I know what you mean. I was bullied a lot as a kid (I stuttered), and I too see bullies in position of power. I’ve had many bosses who were horrible bullies. But even they can be philanthropic, even they can be charitable. Most of the richest people in the world give extensively to charity, and even though it only averages around 10% of their wealth, that’s still more than I, or most people, give. But you’re right. I do look for the good in people. I think being an artist helps me to look for the awe and wonder in all aspects of life. If so, I’m grateful for that. As always, good to talk with you David.

  2. David Pearce Music Reviewer Avatar

    Maybe you don’t but I think the vast majority of people do. I have always thought that people are basically bad and need to be socialised to be good. You only have to look at classes of children at the earliest stages of schooling. Those children who are basically unkind are clear to see and they tend to be the leaders of the class and set the tone. This is why bullying sets in so early because it is more natural for people to follow those who are unkind.

    1. Paul Carney Avatar

      Having taught primary aged children extensively I can say that this isn’t true. Children are born good. They are wonderful. Spend some time in a nursery or reception and it is joyful. Adults could learn a lot from young children, especially around being kind.
      Bullies exist, but they are the exception, or else all children would bully and they don’t. Whenever I’ve encountered extreme bullying I have always seen poor parenting or troubled children.
      Bullies don’t have classes full of followers, they have classes full of people who fear them and avoid them. Nor do they ‘lead’ the class. It’s rare for bullies to excel academically, so they certainly don’t lead there, but they tend to do better in physical lessons such as PE. Bullies are frequently excluded and isolated because of their behaviour, rather than having armies of admirers.
      I’ve lived and worked extensively in the poorest areas of the north east, teaching many kids who no one else would teach and you know what? They were good kids. Yeah they were rough around the edges but they were decent, kind people. And I see this now. Most people will help a neighbour in need. They will look out for the vulnerable and do the decent thing. Yes, there are some bad people, some sick, twisted, and nasty people, but they are invariably the product of a society that has twisted them. There is nothing in DNA that makes them born that way.

  3. Rob McShane Avatar
    Rob McShane

    Great write up and thinking… love your conclusion. Thanks 🙏

  4. David Pearce Music Reviewer Avatar

    Kindness is something that we see around us, but the higher you get in society the rarer it is. This to me indicates that, in general, kind people get nowhere in life, at least to a level to make a difference to everyday life. Therefore there is no benefit to being kind when you get to a certain level. Look at the leaders in every area of life and there is no indication that it is of any benefit in evolutionary terms. I am ready to be convinced otherwise but that could be difficult.

    1. Paul Carney Avatar

      I don’t see kindness as a means of ‘getting on’ or gaining an advantage in life. It is simply a way of making us happier. We get enormous reward from being kind.

  5. Simon Helms Avatar
    Simon Helms

    Thank you for your interesting thoughts, which also strengthen my belief that kindness is part of the Logos. Kindness is inherent in being human. But unfortunately, kindness is not automatically active in humans. It must be learned and can also be unlearned. Those who are kind can feel good about it. However, as the only motivation for merciful action, that is not enough.

    1. Paul Carney Avatar

      I agree, I think we have to find our way to kindness. It’s easier to become waylaid into other ways of being, but I think once you understand it, it becomes an amazing dimension to life. Thank you for your comments

  6. vermavkv Avatar

    This is a beautifully reflective and deeply layered piece. What stands out immediately is how naturally you move from personal experience—your own acts of giving—into something much bigger: a philosophical and almost spiritual exploration of kindness itself.

    1. Paul Carney Avatar

      Thank you. I’m so pleased you saw the positivity in my writing 🙏

  7. Saucertes Avatar
    Saucertes

    Yeah, tell that to my friend who is currently dying because of her kindness to others.

    Giving is enough for some people, in hope of a better outcome for others. The act of giving itself shouldn’t make anybody feel good, nor should there be a need to tell the whole world about it.

    Giving to charities, in any form, is a worthless gesture that stops people just donating to real people in need.

    Charities operate as businesses, replacing community-led initiatives, like ‘Jumble sales” and saying hello to your neighbours in need. Giving to a person, then leaving then to appreciate the act is worth more than the tax avoided by whatever charidee is in fashion today.

It would be great to hear your thoughts about this